Brett GOllumfun Johnson: Marketing Gimmick #1? Dark Web Scanning for Individuals Information

 Worried about your information being for sale on the Dark Web?  DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!  Sorry.  Trying to cue some sort of forbidding music to chime in whenever you read the words, Dark Web.  DUN-DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!  See?  Works out pretty good.  Sets the mood.  Gets you all scared and panicky. like maybe there is a guy with an ax lurking right over shoulder…AHHH!!!!!!

Well, maybe not.  But the question is still there.  Are you worried about your information being sold not only on the Dark Net (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!), but on the internet as a whole to be used by criminals as they see fit?  If you aren’t?  You should be.

As such, there are a few companies out there, Experian being one, which profess to search the Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!) to see if your information is being traded by criminals.

Groovy, right?  No.  Nope, Nope, and Hell Nope.

Before I begin my tirade of the day, let me break with tradition and list the best things readers can do now to protect themselves.

1.       Freeze the Credit of Everyone in the House

2.       Monitor All Accounts and Place Alerts

3.       Use a Password Manager

There is other stuff, but those are some biggies.  Freezing credit stops a thief from opening new accounts.  Monitoring ALL accounts and placing alerts ensures that your existing accounts remain safe and in your control.  A password manager means you aren’t using the same password across multiple sites–as must human beings do.  Just do those three things and you have made a fraudster’s job much more difficult.  So difficult, in fact, he will likely try to rob your neighbor who decided not to do those three things.

That said, let the tirade commence.

Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!) Monitoring.  Egads!  I’ve seen the Experian and Lifelock commercials more than a few times—and I don’t even really watch TV.  My reaction?  Mad cackling.  Wild, Mad Cackling and Belly Laughter followed by my criminal mindset kicking in and asking why I didn’t think of that.

Interesting, I’ve had reporters, members of AARP, producers at 60 Minutes, and more all ask that same question about Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!) monitoring.  In each case, I start with the same hysterical laughter.  Then I have to stop myself from running out and trying to charge some unsuspecting soul for such a useless service.

Useless?  For a person?  Absolutely.  Businesses?  They best be monitoring the Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!) or paying someone to do it for them.  Don’t worry, I’ll explain.

First, you want to know if your info is out there and available to criminals?  IT IS.    See?  Wasn’t that simple?  And you didn’t have to pay some service $120 a year to tell you.  I did it for free.

It works like this:  If a crook can’t pull your SSN and DOB from robocheck.cc for $3, then he can pay another guy $5 to pull it for him.  Credit card compromised?  If isn’t already, it will be.  Think you need be online to be a victim?  Nope.  Last year there were at least 1120 data breaches we KNOW about, which compromised 171 million records.  And that is only what we KNOW ABOUT.  You can bet your last drink of whisky there were many more breaches we don’t know about.  And that is just from last year.  What about previous years?  Oh, my….

Chances of you being a victim of one of those data breaches over the past few years?  High enough you should refer to those three things I listed above which you need to do.

And that is just the illegally obtained information available about you.  There is a plethora of legal information available which criminals can and do access every day.  What do you think a crook does with a background check service?  Or your Linkedin account?  Or Facebook?  Or all the other sites and services which you either contribute information to, or who gather your information to sell to buyers?

So, yeah, your information is already readily available.  Say you haven’t been victimized yet?  Well, that is probably because there is so much stuff out there that your name simply hasn’t come up yet.  And yes, Virginia, there really is that much information out there.

Now we see companies like Experian offering to see if your information is listed on the Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!).

Effective for individuals?  Not in the slightest.

First, your data is already out.  Period.  Next, the advertisement about searching the Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!) for your information?  That is all is it.  An advertisement.  It is designed to get people to trust Experian—or whatever other company is advertising it for individuals—and to sign on, to collect money from uneducated people.

To be a bit more succinct:  A company waves the specter of the Dark Web (You getting tired of the DUN-DUN-DUUUUN thingy yet?  Me too) and tries their best to scare you.  Same company then says they can protect you from this specter and offers a variety of products to keep you safe.

Basically, send us money and we will keep you safe.  People fall for that?  Every. Single. Day.

Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!) Monitoring.  Does it work?

It works great—FOR BUSINESSES AND ORGANIZATIONS WONDERING IF CROOKS ARE TALKING ABOUT RIPPING THEM OFF.  Crooks do that all the time.  Some fraudster finds an exploit with the IRS, or some large retailer, or payment processor?  He shares it with his buddies.  Sometimes he may sell it as a tutorial or teach classes about it.  Pretty soon it makes its way to the masses of whatever Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!) criminal community is open at the time.  It always happens that way.  Specific organizations are discussed daily on the Dark Net.  (Ha!  I didn’t say Dark Web!  Damn.  Just did.  Growl.  DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!).  It is worth it to companies to know if they are being talked about and to try to ascertain how fraudsters are stealing from them.

Individuals?  NO.  Specific individuals are not discussed.  The information of specific individuals is bought and sold.  Meaning it isn’t posted openly on a criminal website for everyone to view.  It is behind a sell wall.  The only time you see personal information posted is when a seller is giving out freebies to verify his product, or when some fraudster has already victimized a person and just puts the information out there for any who want it.  This doe NOT happen often.

Experian claims to scrape dark net websites for your data.  Actually, they say they use a variety of “techniques–including chat room monitoring, crawling/scraping, and forum extraction.”  Meaning?  If a crook happens to post your information on one of the few criminal websites we actually know about, then we have little bots out there that record it and notify you.

Of course, crooks don’t do that.  It defeats the entire business model of cybercrime to post tons of free info.  Info is sold.  Samples are sometimes posted.  Info that is for sale or that has been sold is something that Experian CANNOT get access to.  I mean, at least not by “chat room monitoring, crawling/scraping, and forum extraction”.  Those tools can only find what the site has publicly posted.  All those credit cards for sale, bank accounts, credit reports?  Nope.  Not going to get access to them by scraping a Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!) site.

Admittedly, there are sites out there which list a lot of PII (Personal Identifying Information).  Some of these sites list it for free.  Several sites list hundreds of thousands of email addresses.  Other sites list enough information to identify a specific person but hold back the best parts (SSN, DOB) for a price.  It could be that companies like Experian rely heavily on these types of sites to fulfill the promise of their marketing campaign.  If so, it is a false fulfillment.  The data scraped from these websites, with few exceptions, is either a sampling or so dated to the point as to no longer be newsworthy.  Why?  Because you should already know your information is out there for sale.  The data on those sites tends to be from known breaches ad the victims have already been warned.  Hmm.  I wonder why Experian doesn’t just offer a service warning you if you were a victim of a breach?  Oh yeah, MUCH scarier to use the words Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!).  Probably more profit in that particular word selection.

And Experian wants to charge individuals $120 a year to provide this service?

Experian’s Promise about their Service?  Straight from their website:  “IN NO EVENT WILL EXPERIAN WARRANT OR GUARANTY THE CORRECTNESS, COMPREHENSIVNESS, COMPLETENESS, ACCURACY, TIMELINESS, MERCHANTABILITY, OR FITNESS FOR ANY PARTICULAR USE OR PURPOSE OF ANY INFORMATION, PRODUCTS, OR SERVICES ON THIS WEBSITE.”  Meaning?  Meaning, they would like you to pay them $120 a year for a promise of nothing.

How bout you save your money?  Realize your information is already out there.  You don’t need to pay someone to tell you what you already know.  Start by doing the three things I mention above.  Then start taking a proactive approach to security.

Advice to organizations?  You need to monitor the Dark Web (DUN-DUN-DUUUUN!!!!) for your info.

Source: http://www.anglerphish.com


Discover more from #News247WorldPress

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from #News247WorldPress

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading