Brian Douglas: An insight to why TB is an unstoppable serious health problem in Romania’s rural villages

                                                         Rural Tuberculosis

The hidden underground serious illness

An insight to why TB is an unstoppable serious health problem in Romania’s rural villages.

When we consider that Romania is the E.U country with the highest incidence of tuberculosis; 6 times more than the average E.U then we have to look at determinants of why this is year after year. Let’s look at rural dwelling population and rural lifestyles to see what appears and take into account the view of a medic. Dr. Carmen Dumitreasa in 2015 some 3 years ago highlighted the fact that tuberculosis maintained high values in rural areas, especially in Piatra Neamţ County where she is based.

This is also the case in all of the other northeast Counties of the Country being Iasi, Vaslui, Botosani, Bacau and Suceava.

Every year, more than 1,100 Romanians die of tuberculosis and another 16,000 receive this cumbersome diagnosis that has far reaching effects on them and their families.

Open countryside all around, clean air and much more make you think that life in a village is a healthy one and as I know as have lived in a Romanian village for the last 12 years of the 23 years I have been in Romania and this is only partly the truth. Locals work on their plots of land, walk to the local shops, thus gain physical exercise daily helping their circulation and hearts, but there are factors like age and sex along with ethnicity that affect public health including gaps in medical facilities too.

Women versus men shown that the National Institute of Statistics in 2017 stated that in the rural area, the share of the female population was 49.8%.

The female population is more “aged” than the male with 3.3 years. National average age is 41.7 years, female average age – 43.3 years, and mean male age 40 years. Also most elderly people who are women live in rural areas being 52% of all women aged 65 and over. Emigration of young Romanians is alarming especially in the rural area with over 3.4 million Romanians abroad. This includes many rural young ones either often unqualified looking for work or are in work. In many rural villages today there are few young ones left and of those that are many are young Mothers with children.

The result is a rural population that is aged in the main part and one in which illnesses associated with older age compound TB treatment simply by additional factors. Combine this with the sheer fact that this older generation has very little or no public health education on the tuberculosis subject, not even knowing for instances the signs and symptoms of tuberculosis and clearly here lies a huge problem.

A problem exasperated by the fact that many people in rural areas when feeling ill simply do not visit their family doctor. TB requires immediate diagnosis that can only start at the hands of a medic, yet without knowledge many simply do not realize how ill they are and simply think it’s a cold and take paracetamol tablet or the like. The life becomes in danger and also to other family members from this transmissible TB airborne serious illness. Once diagnosed with TB the problems become more complicated for a rural person immediately.

Treatment is long and means patients will stay in hospital between 6 -12 months often going long periods without a family visitor who lives far away in the rural village and who so often has nu funds to visit and this applies to children with TB as well sadly in marginalized families. Though Tuberculosis treatment is free in Romania there are additional unseen costs including diet extras and as stated above family visits and what about the family left back home, how will they manage to cope without funds?

If the TB infected person is the breadwinner no matter what age or sex they face an immediate dilemma once hospitalized as must be for a lengthy time. This is about the problem of who will put food on the table and pay the bills in this period? It is this factor which sees many renounces hospital life saving treatment when they feel a little better and simply go home and work on the land again.

Then appears further complications as the body is not clear of tuberculosis and now it grows stronger and resistant to drugs MDR-TB and now even with the best medical care all too easily a life can be lost. All this happens because there is simply no social back up for the family left behind and as soon as it becomes known in the village that a member of a family has tuberculosis a terrible stigma that affects the whole family comes into operation and the family which actually needing help and local support is shunned.

Even when the sick person returns to good health after completing the full course of TB treatment they often for instance are stigmatizes as no local employer will employ them not even in outside day work! Because of this the whole family suffers an ongoing and unjust barrier within local society like in the dark ages. Stigmatization holds place simply because of a lack of education about tuberculosis, which in the vast majority of cases is curable if the advice of the medic is adhered to fully.

Lifestyle factors.

Yes, rural life can be healthy, but only if you respect the lifestyle you have been blessed with!

Sadly many do not. I can leave my home any morning in Iasi County and on the road to Suceava City via Botosani Town and I pass many villages and even before firstt light the village bars are open and doing good business. Men on their way to work, some walking, and some on bicycles can be seen taking a glass of alcohol spirits or 2 or 3 and that’s only before work starts.

During the day more alcohol and cigarettes follow outside the bar often in the shade of a tree to a point that their bodies are affected and the person who then say goes out and does hard manual labor for a day on the land often sweats and suffers from the stress of work because the human body cannot cope with such work when fuelled with alcohol and tobacco only. Strong spirit based alcohol though warm is no replacement for solid food.

If the worker is lucky they have a home packed sandwich in many families sent with them as a bite to eat, but it’s far short of what the body requires to replace lost nutrients when working hard outside and illness like TB comes into play here in many cases specially on very hot summer days or freezing winter ones. Being constantly wet also is a major factor in ill health as we all know.

Northeast Romania like other Countries nearby including the Ukraine and Republic of Moldova all benefit from climates that allow alcohol production, even at home level with almost every dwelling having a few rows of grape vines and fruit trees that make tuica a natural strong drink. The Romanian wine even at home level is of a good quality, but just because a family can say produce 130 liters of wine and also many liters of tuica doesn’t mean that it has to be consumed in excess like it is many times endangering public health and inhibiting serious illness like Tuberculosis and liver and kidney disease.

I point out that its not only men who tend to drink in excess, but some women too. Despite the above there are families where they respect alcohol levels and in such cases continue to lead healthier lives.

Infrastructure including rural dwellings.

In the rural villages since Romania joined the EU in early 2007 there have been changes. In many cases brought about at family level by the ones who left to find a higher salary abroad and could afford to forward funds home. Here even women who took jobs in Italy or Spain as housemaids for the elderly in both Countries found they could send home Euro’s each month quite apart from the young men who left even to work unqualified as they gained a far higher salary than even they could dream of back home in Romania and still is the case today.

These funds have I see changed the lifestyle of many families with them being able to afford to modernize their small dwelling in some cases with say new double glazed windows and even piped water supply allowing an inside bathroom with toilet. In other cases there was sufficient funds earned to extend and modernize the small dwelling adding extra rooms, thus creating a better quality of living space for each family member.

Some even managed to earn enough funds over several years to build a completely new modern European style dwelling with all modern amenities. The downside is that in many cases the workers who went abroad didn’t see their children growing up and this has had a social impact on both child and family all too often. Overall though their families standard of living went up!

This though is only part of the story as many didn’t have the same opportunities and still live in old small low roofed mud brick built dwellings with small rooms and sorba wood burning fires that not only provide heat, but also are used for cooking food on and boiling water brought from the street well nearby.

Animal food is also prepared on these wood burning soba fires. Here often can be found pensioners even some living alone and maybe even raising their grandchildren whilst both parents are trying to find work abroad or are working. The steam from the boiling of water and food including animal food rises into the air and as the room with the wood burning small fire is the warmest, often the small kitchen all the family sleep on the sofa bed in this room.

Constant boiling of food that is water based for both human consumption and in other instances for animal consumption means that steam in the air cannot escape as these dwellings have no aid bricks to allow this and as such falls back down in the night as micro water droplets that are breathed in my all who sleep in the small unventilated room including young children. Bedding as the fire falls out in the night becomes damp and often because of a lack of funds to keep the soba fire going 24/7 the room is cold early morning even before residents get up from the sofa bed.

Here is where Tuberculosis reins as is perfect conditions for it to breed from one person to the other. In 2004 I took some sterile small containers into one such dwelling which was mud brick construction as with thick walls and no place for clean air to enter or steamy smoky stale air to leave the rooms I found white mould in the entry to roof space area and scooped same up. I took the sterile containers to University Al Cuza in Iasi where Prof Dr Toma and his colleges had the mould assessed and the result stated that this was a danger to public health with micro organisms and bacteria in the test results.

Walk past many of these old mud brick built dwellings and you if not Romanian might think that this looks a lovely small cottage, in fact I’ve hear foreign people visiting northeast areas of this Country saying just that! As stated above though all is often not what it seems and unless you live here many years and investigate the problem remains hidden as Romanians are rightly so proud people.

Many work hard and are warm by nature thus deserve better than being in 2018 in conditions that may be dangerous to their health often because of ignorance of public health issues and because of a lack of funds. Romanian rural salaries are so low that you can either pay the bills often or afford very basic food, not both!! Many locals travel by maxi busses to towns to work, but once the weekly fares are taken out after all state stoppages the person is hardly any better off and can just manage to get by, nothing extra can be afforded.

It’s a hard life as a ‘navitist’ as the Romanian word is for these people as they have to be up at the crack of dawn and to the village bus stop no matter if is 30c minus outside or a hot summers early morning, rain, snow, dry heat or windy doesn’t matter as must be away to catch that bus to the town which may take and hour of travelling and another hour back after a working day. Few in Europe have perfect working conditions, but rural Romanians have the worst because of circumstances outside their control all too often.

What has this to do with tuberculosis one might ask; well clearly when the human body is weakened it becomes susceptible to illnesses like TB and extra long days at work, plus waiting for busses to and from the village in all weathers do wear one down physically, thus health can become affected. Add to this the fact that the small rural buses are often crowded with people even standing all the journey and it only takes one or two of the passengers to be TB carriers and the spread can affect other travelers who maybe simply sat or stood near the one who was sneezing or coughing, its that simple to spread TB.

TB dispensaries are far too few in the large sprawling rural areas, in fact know villages in areas where there is no family doctor and when sick even with a small illness the person must travel to the nearest village even if by horse and cart and again no matter what the weather be outside

To gain healthcare one must have medical insurance, but at around 466 Euro per year (2100 Ron) the masses including the old people simply have no means to afford this and fear serious illness knocking at their door. Just say though you could afford the medical insurance by chance and then have a bad constant cough, sweat at night, loose weight and feel no interest in life so you go to your family doctor.

The doctor suspects you have either tuberculosis or possibly as the symptoms are similar in other pulmonary diseases and sends you with a doctor’s medical note to the Pneumologie hospital for further examination and tests by a consultant specialist. Now the nightmare starts as many simply can’t afford the travel to the far away town hospital on such low Romanian salaries or social assistance payments, let alone pension payments.

I know people who have never been to the town, sounds crazy to westerners, but here were all is local based in villages this is the case with some people who feel safe and secure in their own surroundings where they are known and lived all the life. Once arriving by bus then is to find the hospital when already feeling low and ill at the same time.

The worry of the family left behind if I have to stay in hospital is high in the mind. Who will look after the animals, feed and water them and the plants we live off in the garden, who will pay the electricity and purchase basics from the shop, even daily bread if I am not there to fund this is often the trauma a person attending a TB hospital suffers, but with no back up for such they are left alone by the state in social terms to suffer.

I was born and raised in another Country and think different, but being in Romania so many years and speaking with the poor when sick I know what their concerns are and appreciate these are real problems that need to be overcome and a huge help would be more localized TB dispensaries in rural areas.

Poverty and hardship in many cases also doesn’t allow parents to visit their children when ill with TB and confined to the pediatric TB hospital section in Iasi. I know a woman in Dorohoi who’s child was interned in Botosani town TB hospital section and she simply had go all day without having anything to either eat or drink as could only just afford the bus fare to go see her child sick with TB and this was a rare visit because of financial hardship and is not a singular case know.

I my 5 years working hands on at the infantile TB Clunet hospital section in Bucium near Iasi city until 2002 I noticed so many times the simple fact that parents didn’t visit and this was often the far away rural ones who simply had no possibility financially or of transport. After the closure of the Clunet outreach TB hospital section over 10 years ago the children with TB are now treated at Pascanu TB pediatric hospital section in Iasi City and the problems of rural visits by family members are the same, plus this TB section is in fact worse than was Clunet hospital section with a massive shortage of space making it very difficult despite the best efforts of medics and nurses to accommodate the many children who arrive from all area of the County infected with TB.

I am not politically involved in Romania, but it’s a clear fact that though the Country is overburdened with tuberculosis cases and now also multi drug resistant cases no government health minister in the 24 years I have been here has seriously addressed this huge problem of TB, yet its curable if the will only existed at top level. Romania has in my opinion the best qualified TB medics with huge experience who even without the best of conditions and with lacks of TB drugs have cured so many, thus treatment including under the D.O.Ts scheme does work.

Any new regional hospitals as planned should include a one stop TB hospital where all people children and adults can be treated in modern European conditions, rather than what we have now and where medics can diagnose faster TB cases when referred. Many medics have left the Country as not only can earn better abroad but have the best working conditions and now we are faced with a shortage of pneumological specialist, yes but right when they are needed with the need for TB regional and rural dispensaries! Its reality but doesn’t make sense I know.

Tuberculosis is an illness within a society that has been failed right from the start with a complete lack of education on the subject at ground level, lack of finance that is required to make the changes to effectively save lives and bring the very high levels of Tuberculosis back down as within many other EU countries. The population deserves better!!

Author Brian Douglas..

21.3.2018

Brian Douglas is a British born Humanitarian aid worker who works in collaboration for many years with Prof Dr Traian Mihaescu and his team of specialists at the Iasi university clinic pulmonary disease hospital in TB prevention and rural problems affecting public health


Discover more from #News247WorldPress

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from #News247WorldPress

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading